Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Catalina - CP #8
Catalina - CP #7
ClassObservation 3_Dallas
Kristen Braun TP# 8&9 Kim
Kim and I met up last Monday and she was very eager to get right into it, telling me she really needed help with speaking and conversations implying that two hour sessions would be fine with her (though that is not fine with me). I talked her into keeping it a an hour and a half twice a week and seeing how that goes.
We did listening exercises with clozed transcripts. I gave her (par her request) homework of listening to one news article and telling me about it the next time we meet.
Which was yesterday. We spent the time talking- Thanksgiving and the Korean equivalent chusuk which is a time to praise the ancestors for the harvest. We talked about my family "Oh! You don't live with your parents? Your brother lives in a different house?" We talked about how in the United States it is a sign of independence and maturity to move out of your folks house as opposed to the expectation in Korea to remain living with one's parents til marriage, men and women alike.
We did more listening exercises, I decided to go up to an advanced dialogue despite her protests and afterward though she claimed to only understand 40% she answered all the questions right. (Much like the students in the last class observation I had with Debbie.) Kim listened to an article about what is going on between South and North Korea. For next our meeting she will first write her summary and then talk about it to keep the explanation succinct.
Monday, November 29, 2010
CP # 2 - Matthew
TP #10 - Matthew
TP #9 - Matthew
I thought it would be a good idea to watch a segment of a movie that is difficult to understand. So, we watched a scene from Braveheart, via Youtube. This way the student could recognize the different dialect of English being spoken. I feel that showing all of the diffferent ways a native English speaker can sound has really allowed my studetns to grasp the English language more confidently. Instead of struggling when a word is not understood, I feel that they are slowly looking past individual words and utilizing the context of the sentences. I wish I had this understanding of learning when I was attempting to learn French because I often struggled with not knowing a single word and did not have this tool of "top-down" reading/listening.
Surprisingly, the student was quite effective in comprehending the English and marked most of the questions I gave him on a worksheet correct. He stated that for some reason, the British/Irish accent was easy to understand because "They do not make words longer". I think he was referring to the shortening of English words by this accent.
It was a fun and successful meeting and I told him that our last meeting on Monday would be of his choosing. Until next time,
Matthew
Kristen Braun TP#6&7 BJ 11/17&1/20
On the 17th I think, I talked to him about stressed and unstressed syllables. Listening to him talk and read I noticed that he wouldn't say or stress the ending syllables of his words as in Tallahass instead of Tallahassee or Tenness. instead of Tennessee etc. I began to think that maybe he does not hear these last sounds b/c they are not as emphasized. It got us into talking about the confusion he's had with others due to this.
So now I get to bring in poetry as an activity on stressed and unstressed syllables! yea!
(These lessons were my 4th and 5th with BJ but including my two meetings with Radka it adds to 6&7. Just to be clear.)
Catalina - CP #6
Sunday, November 28, 2010
Myrick, J. CO #1
Myrick, J. CP #6
Chris - TP#5
I explained to Pete the meanings of some of the words and phrases he had circled. He's a fast learner and was mostly interested in talking about the wars and American history of that era. I told him it would definitely help to watch the movie...I might even watch it myself.
Pete will go back to Taiwan for a little while during the holiday break, but he will be coming back to Tallahassee again after that. I'm sure I'll keep in touch with him next semester.
More to come!
Friday, November 26, 2010
Lindsey CP #4 and #5
Hakan and I also talked a bit about Turkey, since I am interested in the country. He is Kurdish and didn't learn to speak Turkish until he was 12 years old. He also showed me photos (on his laptop) of some of his favorite places in Turkey, like Uzungöl. Uzungöl means "long lake" and is a beautiful resort destination. I hadn't known the word for lake in Turkish, so I gained some knowledge as well!
We also spent time talking about the independent writing section of the TOEFL, since he was working hard to prepare for that. We talked some about content and structure. You could tell he'd listened to American teachers and tutors about what kind of writing is expected in the TOEFL, but also that he came from a very different writing tradition and that it is a conscious effort to remember to write in the Western style. I really wish him well with his upcoming test!
Tuesday, November 23, 2010
TP #8 - Matthew
After this lesson, we talked about the column I chose (which happened to be a soccer write-up about the FSU Womens Soccer team)and I had them write a timed paragraph about soccer/football in their country. They had 8 minutes to produce as many sentences as possible but with cohesion. They both have discussed with me that they lack timed writing skills, so what better way to collaborate a listening lesson with a writing lesson than this! I felt that this was one of my better lessons because it has grabbed a few different aspects of learning as well as kept the students interested in the subject. You could feel the brains thinking and actively engaging the activity.
We plan on another Skype lesson because they seem to be the most convenient. Until next time,
Matthew
CP # 1 - Matthew
Jeffrey is not studying to go to school at FSU, but rather he is waiting for his job to open up in Washington DC in the beginning of January. In the mean time, he thought it would be beneficial to learn more English and take a few courses here at the CIES. He seems rather excited to move to a larger city and I completely understand. Coming from Seoul, living in Tallahassee would be almost the extreme opposite style of living. He made a few references about how one has to drive everywhere and that the public transportation is rather poor.
After a few words with Jeffrey, Nasser came to talk with us as well and we discussed the differences between their countries and how everyone in the United States have been very welcoming and polite. I made it a point that Tallahassee is generally a nice city and that perhaps it would not be as warming in larger cities. All in all, it was a good first meeting and we have plans to meet up over the weekend.
Matthew
TP #7 - Matthew
We practiced by giving him a set time to write a paragraph and it seemed that he was able to generate his ideas and sentences clearly, but the want to make sentences more complex was present. I shared with him the Keep It Short and Simple approach and I think he understood. Overall, it was a good session and I am glad that he has progressed so much these past few weeks.
Until next time,
Matthew
C. Smith - CP No. 6
For this lesson, I met with an online contact of mine named Y--- and we had a conversation over Skype. the changing attitudes of the youth in Japan. We then discussed the reasons for studying other languages as well as Eastern philosophy and what it can teach people in the 21st century.She is a volunteer who helps people down on their luck who do not have anyone to talk to. She gradually became more interested in traditional Japanese thought as she grew older.
I discussed the contrasting ideologies of Iskandar, who was versed in Aristotle and the holy man he came across whose name escapes me for now. Thanks to the magic of the blog, that will be rectified later on today. After we mentioned this, we talked about the Eightfold Path and how we implement it into our own lives.
C. Smith - CP No. 5
Although I have taught Mohammad and his wife as a TP, this meeting was far more informal. I visited Mohammad at his house. His friend Abdullah was there along with an Indian man named Naneed (I may not have remembered that correctly). I first talked with Mohammad about ideas for the comic strip he had to draw to depict the working conditions of young doctors, and then we broke for lunch.
He had prepared kabsa with a side of salad, and we also had the shicaccia I bought at Publix. After having lunch, we had arabic coffee (which is amazing, by the way) and then Mohammad showed me photos of a rite he and Abdullah participated in for Eid al-Adha. Mohammad had clearly performed this rite many times and handled the preparation and division skillfully. It was very interesting to see the photos.
Monday, November 22, 2010
Victoria - Class Observation 3
I sat with two students, one was Turkish named Bader ( I hope I spelled that correctly) and the other I think was Chinese, but I don't remember her name. They were handed back their error logs and went over them to find their mistakes. I was glad to see this method in action and I really liked it. The students I sat with went over their sentences and asked me when they did not know what they did wrong. I also helped them with their pronunciation, which the Chinese girl had more of a problem with. There was one sentence in particular that Bader wrote that I just could not correct. Ramin sat down with him and asked him what he was trying to say in this sentence. They concluded that his problem was not using enough background information to explain what he was trying to say. He needs to think in parts of a main idea. He needs to try not to bite off more than he can chew and start with smaller more manageable sentences and ideas. It was a wonderful class and most people were eager to speak.
Victoria TP 3!!!
Bushra did not know that there was going to be such a hub-bub like that and apologized since it was a little hard to hear. We focused that time on learning about each other and finding out what she needs help with. She says she has only been learning English for 4 months. I think she is pretty amazing. She says she needs help being able to spell words that she has never seen written down and that she wants to work on her vocabulary and grammar.
Maybe coming from Miami where you can get by only with Spanish I have lower expectations of people. Most of these people would be able to live happy lives in Miami with the amount of English they know. It is so impressive how fast these people learn. It gives me hope for when I go to Colombia. I figure I already have a head start on that anyway.
We had planned on meeting today but she called me and told me that she was sick. So my quest to collect my TP sessions has been foiled again. But have no fear I still have high hopes of finishing on time(ish).
On a slightly unrelated note... Cati and I had a cultural adventure on Friday night that sampled a little of everything Tallahassee has to offer. We even commandeered this old man's popcorn. He was too busy groovin' and cruisin' too miss it. We met the most amazing woman with an incredible life story and then some drunk hippies too. Like I said, cultural adventure. Isn't that why we are all here?
Sunday, November 21, 2010
Victoria TP 2!!
I don't know if she understands exactly how to continue her learning. She complains about her teachers instead of looking at a way that she could improve. I think that it is neat that I can see improvement in her conversation skills. She still needs loads of practice because she is still very limited in what she can communicate but I see her trying really hard.
Victoria CP 7
Her daughter's birthday was the Friday after we met and she turned 2!! How exciting! This little girl is so cute. She loves Florida State and every time she sees any FSU shirt or watches the game with her dad she does the war chant and the chop constantly. Now that is a fan! Our smallest but biggest fan.
Victoria CP 6
I took Latifah to the art museum on campus and it was wonderful. She was fascinated by all the different art methods and styles. She told me what would be acceptable in Saudi Arabia and what would not be allowed. I had to explain the word abstract to her. Luckily she is already an art teacher and is familiar with the methods and so it wasn't that difficult. I had a wonderful time and it was really neat seeing the art through her eyes. I think she is a better artist than what we saw in the gallery.
Catalina - CP #5
Saturday, November 20, 2010
Daniel Fletcher CP#4
Taylor CP #4
I also got to meet Hasan and Jackie. It is crazy what Hasan is studying here and I really did not understand completely what he was going to do at Penn State (or UPenn, I get the two mixed up) but something with the human eye and a hawks eye with the zoom. I also had some interesting conversations with Jose about Chavez, the US army, and culture differences. He told me Chavez keeps taking land and kept asking me what I thought about the US troops in Iraq. I really did not expect him to be so political but they were interesting conversations to say the least! I also asked him if there was anything shocking about the US compared to Venezuela and he thought the amount of cars here is ridiculous. After awhile his friend from Spain showed up. I don't remember his name because I tried to talk to him but he was so quiet! Well, quiet until Jose got him a drink and tipped the bartender ONE dollar. Then he kept calling Americans capitalists and did not understand that this is how people make their money here. I was trying to keep it light but he was still oddly angry. Eventually a few of my friends showed up and they kept cheating and talking to Jose in Spanglish but everyone seemed to be enjoying the conversations and songs. Sam and Jackie got up and sang and we cheered them on and Hasan even got up to sing! But, Jose and I were too scared and just cheered everyone on! Eventually the crowd died down and we decided to leave.
So I parked my car in what I thought was the "overflow lot" at Aj's. I have parked there before and everything was fine. However, this time, my car was gone! A fresh tow-away zone sign was on the curb covered by a short trees branches! I did not know what to do because I needed to take home two international students. After about 20 minutes, my roommate picked us up and got everyone home. I felt so bad that they had to wait! Anyway, I hope they had a good time, it really was an authentic Tallahassee experience with the karaoke and towing situations.
Taylor: TP #5
Chris - CP#2 (Meeting with Jia)
Last Thursday I got to meet with Jia Moon at tea time. It didn't take long for me to realize that her language skills are a bit lower than my other CP and my tutee. I think it's good that I have to add the extra effort to get my point across. Jia just arrived here from Korea about a month ago. We talked about the differences between Korea and Florida. I told her about how I am secretly a big fan of Korean music. It always surprises the Korean students when I start naming bands.
Jia told me that she wants to get better at English, but she doesn't feel she's improved much yet. I told her that the first few months are the toughest and that it wall all click soon. She seems to have a very positive outlook on everything and that's half the battle. Sometimes she doesn't understand me, but she wants to so she keeps trying.
Once we got to know each other more, we realized that she is a lot older than me. She said that in Korean, I would call her "Noo Na" because she is an older girl. So that's what I've decided to start calling her.
I look forward to meeting with her again soon.
Dallas CP3
Dallas-CP2
Classroom Observation 2
Friday, November 19, 2010
Daniel Fletcher TP#1
Merve is from Turkey and actually knows three other Turks and classmates at CIES who also decided to come to Tallahassee to learn English (One of these others is my conversation partner, Ohnurhan from Turkey). She plans on taking the TOEFL exam in December.
Because it was our first meeting, I had no lesson planned, but I saw that she needed help with speaking, I helped her with pronunciation with the difficult consonant sounds in English; such as: p, th, sh, b, and z. Then we moved to the different vowel sounds (English vowels are difficult because their are no accent marks). The lesson was finished with a discussion of syllables and my attempt at accurately pronouncing Turkish sounds (I hope Merve feels more confident in her-self after she sees that we all struggle with new sounds).
Daniel Fletcher Class Observation #3
I thought that I would not be able to teach a class like this because of the "issues" previously mentioned, but now I believe I could, I understand why the class is conducted in this manner, and why the teacher allows certain things I previously thought rude.
C. Smith - CP No. 4
The other day at tea time I spoke with Kei on the subject of nostalgia. We both talked about favorite games and books from our youth. Because I was around during the 80's, our memories didn't always match up, but I think reflecting upon the time when we were children and not dealing with grown-up stuff was fun for both of us.
Kei told me that he had trouble finding thinly sliced cuts of meat. He wants to make yakiniku As I write this tonight, I realize how much I'm going to miss the work we do for the class. I've still got quite a bit left to do, so I'll make the most of this weekend and the week ahead .... I suggested that he get in touch with the butcher at his local supermarket and taught him some phrases with which he can hopefully convince the man to chop the meat into the thin strips that Kei needs for his dish.
/p>
C. Smith Blog Post: Legal Violations in ALT Private Dispatch Companies in Japan
In August of 2009 I was hired by Interac, a private education firm, to teach in Japan as an Assistant Language Teacher. I was looking forward to the work and I was excited to be able to go back to Japan. Though things started to turn bad fairly quickly, I tried to make the best of it. I think my first inkling that something wasn't right was being told after I arrived that I wasn't going to draw my first paycheck for two months. That was just the opening volley.
This essay is to persuade you to avoid working for Interac and other haken companies in Japan.
Some background information is necessary to understand what is happening and why. Public schools in Japan are required by law to have a foreign speaker of English on hand to instruct the students at the school, but the schools are free to choose how to address this problem. Some use the JET program, others opt for direct hire of a foreign instructor, and some others use gyomu itaku (service contracts), which are offered by private language teaching companies such as Interac, . These firms use 派遣社員 /hakenshain (temporary workers or permatemps) as teachers in schools under short-term contracts. These contracts are in fact illegal. According to the Ministry of Education, the principal must be in charge of all teachers at his (or her) school, but under gyomu itaku contracts, the company is in charge of the employee.[1]
These contracts are popular with school boards because of the relative low cost of the instructor and the ability to quickly replace a teacher without the possibility of negotiation. The positions offered by these companies are very unstable; if the board of education complains (for whatever reason), the company can lose the contract for that school and the teacher can be summarily dismissed. It is extremely easy to fire a haken employee; the easiest way is not to renew his temporary contract at the end of his service. This is unfortunately a very real possibility. The Tokyo General Union estimates that there is a 50% chance of an ALT quitting or being fired unfairly because of unfair working conditions [2].
These unfair working conditions include not enrolling teachers in shakai hoken, the national health insurance plan, the social pension plan, paying teachers for the hours they work, or the constant fear of being fired. At one training meeting I attended, I was told that we might have to wait for a phone call in between school semesters to find out if we still had a job and would go in to work the next day. These conditions are unacceptable for any professional teacher. To be told that you suddenly have no job with the rent due date coming soon and no way home is something I hope none of you have to experience.
The work itself was at times acceptable, but there were many aspects of it that were unsavory. I was at school from 8 to 5 every day, but I was only paid for 29.5 hours a week. My former employer often split its workers time between “Maxceed” and “Interac” (which are in reality the same company) simply to avoid paying the unemployment insurance it is required by law to its employees [3]. The fact that I was employed by a private dispatch company, not the school itself, also complicated things quite a bit. One of my schools (in fact the one that cost me my job) asked me to prepare lesson plans for the students, but only did so in a very vague way. I remember being told to prepare "interesting lessons", but I never received any guidance from them even though I submitted my lesson plans well in advance of the actual teaching days. The letter I wrote to them after I was fired read thusly:
This kit is for [redacted] and [redacted].
I wanted to give you something. These are my lesson plans and various items I used.
I hope that you will find them useful.
There is something you should be aware of. For the amount of money being paid to your haken teachers, you will only get young people fresh out of college who happen to like Japan. You will not be able to afford a person trained as a high school teacher with a degree in Education. It is simply not possible.
I wanted to be a part of your school. I paid for my plane ticket to and from Japan, for my car, for all the things I used in class, for my gas, indeed, for everything. My first paycheck, after rent was deducted, was a paltry 54,000 yen [editor's note: about 646 dollars, and I got that after waiting two months for my first paycheck]. Still, I had come to work. I was ready to work in a professional environment.
That's not what I got.
When I worked for you, you told me to plan the entire curriculum for your students.
I received no feedback or guidance from either one of you. I submitted my lesson plans to you well in advance . If you disliked something, or wanted to change something, you had only to say so. I was told to make interesting lessons, but no matter what I tried, there was no pleasing you, even if I mimicked the plans of the previous teacher you think so highly of.
I did not appreciate your standing beside me and badmouthing me in Japanese as if I couldn't understand.
But I'm getting sidetracked now, so I need to state my main point clearly:
You're in charge of the program at your school. The ALT is not. The ALT is an _Assistant_ Language Teacher. Perhaps you don't happen to like dealing with foreigners at your school, but that is part of your job. The ALT is not someone you can just foist all of your teaching responsibilities onto, especially when he is an underpaid, overworked, and underappreciated temporary hire.
I hope that you will be a better guide for the foreign teachers that come to your school in the future. Perhaps then you won't have a new one coming in every three to five months. You also won't have to lie to your students about how the ALTs keep quitting due to "health reasons".
That's about all I wanted to say.
-Smith [4]
As Louis Carlet noted, schools want to avoid the responsibility of directly hiring foreigners, but want the right to fire them at will [5].
My experience is not an isolated incident. I'd also like to direct your attention to a particular documentary describing the issues faced by haken ALTs[7]. The part I want you to see starts from 0:29 in the film. Eric, a teacher on a temp contract who was fired, speaks about how his life is now unstable and he is unable to save any money, that he was paid only for days worked in December (leaving him with about $1000 in pay for that month, which rent quickly ate into). I recognize the Interac paystub shown in the video, which means he worked for the same company. He also observes that there have been some months he's been so broke he's used his credit card to pay the rent. He tried to weather through the difficulty and continue teaching, but his contracts were always for 6 months at a time, and he could be terminated at any time. He complains bitterly about not receiving shakai hoken and pension payments because the company fudged his hours and tried to use that as justification for not enrolling him in these systems. By making his official working day between 8:30 and 4:30 pm (and requiring him to be on school premises between 8 and 5), the company was able to accomplish this. The video goes on to note that the Osaka Board of Education determined that these conditions were illegal. When he was summarily dismissed (see 0:54 in this video link no explanation was given or offered to him. The General Union comments that unless conditions improve, English education will be impossible in Japan. At 3:00, we are paid a visit to Robert-san's apartment as he deals with his dwindling savings caused by his dismissal by subsisting on bean sprouts and a 100 yen cut of salmon. After being fired by Interac, he has since been unable to find work in Japan. At 3:55 in the video, he again observes that no reason was given to him. Much later on in the video, students are asked to raise their hand if their school has changed Assistant Language Teachers more than five times in one year (and all of them raise their hands). The students are apparently being told the teachers quit because of "health reasons". One young boy comments that he's had his English teacher changed more than eight times in the same year, and the young lady states that she's had her teacher changed more than four times in the same year. This is completely unfair to the children and robs them of having the chance to have a professional, experienced teacher of English.
The report continues to note that while the JET teachers seemed more friendly, the haken ALTs seem far more reluctant to spend time with the children. Based on my own experience, being mistreated by my employer made it harder for me to do my job. Knowing that I was in danger of being fired, or (towards the end of my employment) working while knowing I was going to be dismissed made it harder for me to concentrate on doing my job.
The upshot of what happened to me, once it was brought to the attention of the General Union, is that Interac was found guilty of unfair labor practices by the Osaka Prefectural Board and forbiden the Osaka Board of Education from entering into contracts with Interac [6]. The General Union was very supportive and I am thankful for their help. Unfortunately, I still lost my job by not being rehired at the end of my contract. The three months I spent looking for work and trying to avoid spending money were emotionally exhausting and in the end I had to ask my parents for money to fly back to America. I probably lost close to $6000 as a result of this entire experience (buying plane tickets to and from Japan, the car I needed to do my job, miscellaneous expenses, key money for the apartment, etc.). If I had to describe this experience in one word, 'horrific' seems to sum it up adequately. I was able to salvage something out of the experience because of my interest in Japan and ability to communicate, but a person totally new to Japan would be unable to rely on either of those for comfort. As the Tokyo General Union noted, these scofflaw contracts not only lower respect for ALTs, teachers, and lecturers, but for the administrators that rely on them, and education as a whole.
I would like to conclude this post by strongly urging all of you to not work for Interac or other haken companies. You deserve better. The schoolchildren of Japan deserve better, too.
1 - http://alt.150m.com/
2 - http://tokyogeneralunion.org/issues/ALT/
3 - http://interacunion.org/2010/10/01/open-letter-to-kevin-salthouse/#more-399
4 - personal letter to a certain high school, sent before I had to leave Japan
5 - http://search.japantimes.co.jp/member/member.html?fl20041214zg.htm
6 - http://www.generalunion.org/alt/news/741
7 - リアル特集+ (Real Special Edition). Aired on Nihon Terebi, July 17 2009.
Kristen Braun Observation #3 Debbie Carretta 11/16
Debbie would stop on the more difficult/ obscure words or phrases and explain them by asking the class then defining with an example as explanation.
A relaxed class but a good example of class-wide extensive reading/ listening. I wishg I sat in on iot before my Listening Lesson project!
CP#5-Tuba-11/18
She and I have naturally fallen into talks about faith/ religion from day one. I'm a little wary about getting into the "God" talk in fear of seeming as though I am proselytizing but I also think that being a typical American presbo is a decent means of comparison for communication's sake. It seems despite our different religions we have a similar faith.
Her test is the 3rd of December and she is nervous! She improves every week and has become more and more confident with talking and listening.
Sam - CP - 4
Sam - TP - 3
C. Smith - TP No. 12
This morning I logged on to teach Takahiro Shioji, a student of mine who is preparing to take the TOEIC exam. I noted that another teacher had used some online TOEIC preparation material to teach him a lesson, so for part of my lesson I used a TOEIC vocab quiz and talked about the words. The rest of the class was mostly spent trying to change Japanese expressions into English (which is a challenging task! Many of the set phrases can be used in a variety of different situations, meaning that when you translate them, those 3-4 words become almost a paragraph of text).
After that, we discussed expressions such as winded, being blue in the face, getting the wind knocked out of you, getting your second wind, showing someone the ropes, etc. We also spoke about work and how to say some common work expressions. I mentioned the importance of talking about stress in order to avoid bottling things up. We then discussed things that we were going to do on our days off this weekend.
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Catalina - Class Observation #3
There is a very big difference in the class. Those that know the American alphabet are focused on their actual composition whereas most of the students are still struggling with capitalization, punctuation, spelling, etc. I can't even imagine how difficult evaluation has to be. Ron lets the more advanced students write the compositions on the computer, since this will change automatically the smaller errors and is a good practice for academic composition writings, while the other student still have to write their compositions down. When the students are divided by groups, he walks from one to another helping out with their composition and pointing things out. The Arab girls are still talking to each other in their native language at times, even though they have a South Korean in their group! I end up working with a girl from Venezuela that had missed the previous classes on her composition. We do some brainstorming and organization of ideas for the paper. Slowly but surely Ron has managed to engage all the students in the class, including myself, and they all end up working despite their initial uninterest. I am impressed at his subtle perseverance. Oh, and have I mentioned I love his accent? I am sure Matthew would appreciate its southern quality....
C. Smith - TP No. 11
We also covered how to complain about particular things to the front desk and brainstormed for things to complain about (no hot running water, messes on the floors, unmade beds, etc.) After we had covered that, we did some speaking drills to reinforce concepts.
Finally, after all of that, we did a roleplay where Radka had to book a hotel room over the phone and get them to hold the room while she was arriving late. The roleplay required her to pay with her card and specify what kind of room she wanted to get (with a King sized bed).
C. Smith - Class Observation No. 3
This class was a grammar class, and it was reviewing their use of questions. Instead of turning it into a writing exercise, Ah-Young played a game with them. The class was divided into 3 teams. One team was shown a secret word, and the other teams had to take turns asking questions about it. The questions they were able to ask were limited:
Five Yes/No questions
5 Wh type questions (including How)
2 Tag Questions
4 Choice Questions
The first questions in each round were usually shaped to determine whether the object in question was a person, a thing, or a phenomenon. Sample questions included 'where can you get it' and 'what do you use it for'.
The game was surprisingly hard for the students because although they knew a lot of vocabulary, they did not know name brands for things (post it notes, scotch tape, etc.) which impeded their ability to guess. As they made questions and guessed, Ah Young took notes on what they said. After the game was over, she wrote sentences on the board and had students correct them.
Where can
It
Who
Children under 5
Wednesday, November 17, 2010
Chris - Class Observation # 3
I saw many familiar faces in the class, including my tutee, Pete. I'm becoming more and more a part of CIES myself these days; I'll have to stay involved next semester. The class continued planning out a debate which is taking place in tomorrow's class. The question was "Should same sex marriage be legalized?" I asked around to see if the class had come up with this on their own, which they affirmed (you all remember my risky speaking lesson about abortion, I'm sure). Interestingly enough, the class seemed to be divided into teams based on how they actually felt about the topic. There was a group of three people who were judges. Their job was to judge the debate based solely on the clarity of the arguments. Ms. Kim would judge everyone on the linguistic aspects. I got to look over one of the instruction sheets and saw that the debate was meant to be very civil and organized, with time allotted for each team to speak and cross examine one another.
Overall, I think I enjoyed this class the most for the cheery atmosphere. Everyone was awake and ready to work, but also not afraid to joke around a bit.
Chris - TP # 4
Today I woke up early and headed over to TCC to see what this ESL class was all about. A friend of mine told me about it and said that the teacher is always looking for volunteers to help out. It was from 9-12 and I couldn't imagine what they could possibly do in there for three hours without getting bored. Not to mention, it's Monday through Thursday.
Most of the students were ladies older than me who were born in other countries and working on their English. However, there was one African guy (I didn't get to talk to him so I'm not sure what country) and, although he sat in the back, he made himself heard. I'd say about half of the ladies were Spanish-speaking and the rest were a mix of various African countries (Ethiopia, Sudan) and Middle-Eastern.
The teacher is a young woman named Kristina Pereira, who teaches at TCC and is involved with PACE. It was immediately clear that she spoke Spanish because she would sneak in some quick explanations to the Hispanic students. I'm not sure if this is a good idea because they should be learning to understand explanations in English, and that kind of alienates half the class. She told me that it was only her second week with that group of students though, so she was still feeling everyone's skill levels out. She was very happy to have me there to help.
When I first got there, some higher-up people at TCC came in and asked us to help them shoot a promotional video for the conference center. It was funny because most of the ESL students that volunteered weren't exactly sure what they were signing up for. We just sat around a conference table while they filmed for a minute. The TCC ladies asked me to communicate the point of the video to everyone, which I thought was silly, since I just repeated what they said in English. Then the ladies kind of laughed when I didn't translate into Spanish. I decided not to waste the effort in telling them that Spanish isn't spoken in Ethiopia or Slovakia...
Then it was back to the classroom. There was a reading about the occupations of a couple different people and the educations they received to get those jobs. I circulated while the students worked on those, offering assistance wherever I could. I saw that this was truly a mixed level class and Kristina dealt with it in this case by telling the more advanced students to write in complete sentences.
Halfway through the class, Ms. Pereira told me that the administrators at TCC sent her an email about me being there. Basically, they said they'd rather me not be there because the liabilities they'd have to deal with if I somehow died in the classroom would be too much to bear. We both laughed this off and filled out the necessary paperwork.
Then we moved on to contractions. There were two worksheets, with fill-in-the-blank problems using contractions. This was just a warm-up for contraction bingo. The bingo sheets had contractions written in each square and Kristina would read a sentence with one contraction in it. This was a great listening activity. There were a lot of false bingos, but that's OK. It was hard to help the students with this one without giving away the answer. All of the students really liked playing the game; it was a great way to end the lesson.
I really enjoyed spending time in this class. While it was more like a class observation at times, I got numerous opportunities to go around and work with individuals. The students thanked me for coming at the end. I'll go back next Monday and probably every Monday and Wednesday until the end of the semester.
Catalina - TP #12
We started the class in one of the classrooms at CIES, and I wanted to drop a bit of the grammar oriented tutoring to try and focus on composition since I have read the latest papers by both of them and they need to work on their sentence structure. We started with writing on the board what ideas they have on what you can do on a free day. With brainstorming came many sentences and actions, until the board was full. Then I asked them how they would organize a composition on ‘What would you do on a free day?’ and how they simply had to combine and connect what they had already said. I was going to give them some time to actually write the text and then go over the structures when Jia freaked out. She was having boyfriend problems and was a mess, and could not concentrate on the writing. It was hugging time and chocolate time, so I stopped the tutoring session and all three of us went to Circle K, I bought some snacks for all of us (and diet coke to compensate, of course) and we sat at one of the small booths to finish the lesson.
The informal setting had helped Jia calm down and I decided we would just finish the pronouns activities we’d started the previous day. This way Hanan wouldn't feel bad about the time she was taking off from her son to be in the tutoring, and she'd feel as if she'd accomplished something. Although relative pronouns became an issue - and I discovered how much I actually don’t know about them while trying to explain them- we ended up finishing all the pronoun activities. We went over ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ together, because Hanan preferred to do it as a group instead of filling it up first and then correcting, and it ended up being a very good idea. It kept Jia concentrated and not overwhelmed, and they both could explain why they chose one form of pronouns or another to each other! They really liked the story, I thought it was funny how they really enjoyed a children’s tale. I guess no one ever truly grows up! It ended the class on a lighter note and, I hope, kept Jia from worrying for a while.
Catalina - TP #11
So Tuesday rolls around and Emma comes to pick me up, starting off with apologies that I shrug off... and there we go to class again! I can say our relationship has grown stronger, yet I try to keep myself objective towards everything. They confide in me and have given me, over our sessions, a lot of very personal and maybe dangerous information. I wonder if it affects the classes in anyway and would like to see myself in the first sessions to recognize the differences.
This time for sure we were going to keep the lesson useful and communicative, so I prepared information that you might need for a hotel reservation and/or payments through the phone. Role playing with a phone conversation was how we approached this, but I’m pretty sure stuff like ‘what is your card number?’ or ‘what is your billing address?’ can come in handy at many situations. We went over numbers too, and Tony was happy about it, since it’s very important to write amounts correctly on checks. We started with the basic payment information and then added to actual hotel information towards the end of the lesson. I had printed out many payment form papers, so we role played for a while. When it was my turn to be the client, they both hated it, since they had to ask me several times to spell things out and they are still having problems with the vowels in the alphabet!
What made me feel really good is that, after the lesson ended they actually wanted to go over ‘Hello, Godbye’. They don’t hate the Beatles! They actually have grown to like the song and wanted to sing it! (Well, it’s more like muttering it under their breath, but, heck! It was their idea and that is enough for me!). You say stop, and I say go go go!
Catalina - TP #10
Anyway, on Monday I thought trying a Cloze test with ‘Hello Goodbye’ by The Beatles would be a good idea. Boy how wrong I was! And I even thought, before going, that the song would be too simple and they would be a bit disappointed that I considered them such a low level… well, that didn’t happen! ‘Hello Goodbye’ took us about an hour and a half. Beatles, I hate you. We listened to it a ton of times, went over all the vocabulary, spoke about contraries and comparisons, and listened to it another ton of times. The problem was that neither of them believed that they could ever understand the song and they were not capable of comprehending they could get most of the vocabulary through context or even copying it from another sentence, since it was a very repetitive song. This is where their non-academic background really became obvious. When we were finally able to finish the song, they were curious about the other activity I had brought in the sheet. Since we would be talking about comparisons in the song, I thought it would be good to introduce the structure of comparatives and superlatives in English. They were already tired but headstrong about finishing the day activities, so we started out with them. About twenty minutes into the comparatives I suddenly asked myself “what am I doing? This is definitely not a priority to learn, it’s completely grammar based and they are not going to have to apply it to communication any time soon.” That’s when I stopped. And I told them! I told them I think it was wrong that we spent too much time on the theory of comparatives and superlatives because they were not going need to use them immediately and that we should focus on more practical things. We went over some examples they might find: ‘cheaper prices!’, ‘the fastest oil change’, ‘the best deals in town’… and after such a long and grueling session decided to end it there. Ugh! How could I have not realized when I was organizing the class that this was not a good idea?
Chris - TP#3
We got into talking about modals, which Pete said he was very confused with. He had a worksheet for homework and after my first glance at it, I admitted that I was also a little confused with some of the examples. It was tough to describe to him the differences between "could, should, must, may, might, etc." Pete doesn't get discouraged easily and beared with me. I tried my best and I think that I helped Pete's understanding of modals in the end.
I asked Pete if he wanted to continue reading the exchange student journals from the Rotary website. He asked me just to give him the link rather than read it together. I'm excited that he showed some interest in reading in his free time. He's clearly beyond the point of intensive reading limitations.
Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Lindsey CP #3
Midway through the drop-in session, two Chinese girls arrived. I switched gears a bit and we all introduced ourselves. Then I led a small group discussion between the 4 of us about travel. I asked them about different places they had traveled while they had been in the States - in Florida and elsewhere - as well as any travel plans they had coming up. I think it was a topic that interested everybody. At the end they all asked if I would be back the same time next week and I felt awful that I had to tell them no because my working hours changed. Hopefully a great ECC volunteer took over!
Lindsey TP #4 and #5
We met again on Saturday, again at a Starbucks near her house. Unlike the last time we had met there, she had already ordered her own drink by the time I arrived. I congratulated her on doing it by herself! During our session I was reminded again how speaking with a non-native speaker can make you question your own understanding of some words. For instance, I used the word 'duplex' in our conversation and when she queried it I struggled a bit to answer. "A duplex is like two houses that are attached. But only one story, otherwise it's a townhouse. Or can a duplex be 2 stories? And a row of more than 2 is still a duplex, right?" None of which is helpful to Y who is staring at me confused. I left her with the notion that it was a place to live in, but not a stand alone structure. Sometimes sharing a general sense of meaning is the best you can do.
Lindsey - Class Observation #3
While observing wasn't particularly useful grammar-wise, it was an interesting class anyway. The students had no motivation to begin their work, and most didn't even try to start. So Anisa had to spend the whole hour motivating them. She went over the assignment criteria multiple times to make sure they understood, and wrote several examples/suggestions on the board. She also repeatedly reminded them that the benefit of getting a good start on the work in class was that there would be less to do at home. Still, it was like pulling teeth to get them to write down anything. But she didn't give up!
Myrick, J. CP#5
For our most recent 'hangout', I decided to take Onur to a movie on campus, which proved to be a good time. We saw the movie, "Scott Pilgrim VS the World", and it was a great movie. It was about this guy who has to fight these seven evil ex-bf of this girl he fell in love with. It's a comedy that I thought that Onur would be confused about a lot of the parts in the movie but he understood about 98% of the movie. He told me that it was his 1st time going to the SLC movie theater and he thought the movie was very funny. I noticed that he likes to laugh a lot, so I might take him to the Comedy Zone the next time we hang out.
Cheers!